I reply simply that the Fountain was not made by a plumber but by the force of an imagination; and of imagination it has been said, “All men are shocked by it and some overthrown by it.”’ She added, ‘there are those who anxiously ask, “Is he serious or is he joking?” Perhaps he is both! This was about 48% of all the recorded Deschamps's in the UK. Tate’s work is a 1964 replica and is made from glazed earthenware painted to resemble the original porcelain. The society’s board of directors, who were bound by the Society’s constitution to accept all members’ submissions, took exception to Fountain, believing that a piece of sanitary ware – and one associated with bodily waste – could not be considered a work of art and furthermore was indecent (presumably, although this was not said, if displayed to women). Search by Search ID or Tag or use the Advanced Search. SP-17-42028. Arnaud Deschamps. With the support of some backers, he and his close friends Henri-Pierre Roché (1879–1959) and Beatrice Wood (1892–1998) produced the first dada periodical in New York, titled pointedly the Blindman, on the first day of the show in part to celebrate (and in part to observe and comment upon) ‘the birth of the Independence of Art in America’ (Henri-Pierre Roché, ‘The Blind Man’, Blindman, no.1, 10 April 1917, p.3). … there is among us to-day a spirit of blague [joke] arising out of the artist’s bitter vision of an over-institutionalized world of stagnant statistics and antique axioms.’ Louise Norton, ‘“Buddha of the Bathroom”’, Blind Man, no.2, May 1917, p.6.) That doesn’t mean we have to take it seriously. The replicas were probably manufactured in Europe by a sanitary ware manufacturer using a conventional slip-cast technique. Us with Team Ryan … Nude Descending a Staircase, … Jan 12, 2019 permalink. in Urban Life & Travel Magic: the Gathering. The most Deschamps families were found in Canada in 1911. Marcel Duchamp's scandalous L.H.O.O.Q is an altered postcard reproduction of Leonardo Da Vinci's Mona Lisa. Young adult book covers. Courtesy of Francis M. Naumann Fine Art, New York. Subsequent investigation showed that original paint layers, including a grey alkyd primer and titanium white alkyd top coat, were still present under several alternating layers of nitrocellulose paints and varnishes. Is this urinal ‘art’ because it is being presented in a gallery? Check out the page below, which showed an early concept that … Gammel noted that von Freytag-Loringhoven was in Philadelphia in spring 1917, linking this to some unsourced press reports at the time of the scandal of the work having originated in Philadelphia, and concluded, ‘there emerges the question of whether the rabble-rousing Baroness may have had a hand in the mysterious Fountain … While final evidence of the Baroness’s involvement may be missing, there is a great deal of circumstantial evidence that points to her artistic fingerprint’ (Gammel 2002, p.225). Cindy Deschamps. Standard urinal cisterns flush as soon as they are full. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.) Sight: 12-1/4" H x 15-3/4" W, Framed: 25" W x 28-1/4" H. Gabriel Deschamps was born in 1919 and studied at the Ecole Nationale des Beaux Arts in Paris. Since so little was published on Duchamp, the article seems to have been based on in-depth conversations with the artist. This web page shows only a small excerpt of our Deschamps research. Four further examples were also made at this time, one each for Duchamp and Arturo Schwarz, and two for museum exhibition. Art gallery situated at 168 Bond Street, London run by the dealer Charles William Deschamps (1848–1908). Contact Information. Duchamp, wanting to submit an artwork to the “unjuried” Society of Independent Artists’ salon in New York—which claimed that they would accept any work of art, so long as the artist paid the application fee—presented an upside-down urinal signed and dated with the appellation “R. Wile the smells may not be beautiful, Urinals are... Gerson Cabrera (@gersoncabrera) 89 Posts; 44 Following; 15465 Followers; 74 Loves; Tsai-Ju Wu (@zaiw) 19 Posts; 43 Following; 893 Followers; 7 Loves; drawing lines and shadows. Whether Mr Mutt with his own hands made the fountain has no importance. Then we checked out the films and our work by Lizzie Fitch and Ryan Trecartin at the Musee d’art modern de la ville de Paris. Mar 30, 2012 - Marcel Duchamp was one of the most influential artists of the 20th century. It also doesn’t mean that we can’t revel in the, 10 New Yorkers Weigh in on Cattelan’s Gold Toilet at the Guggenheim, Vivian Springford’s Hypnotic Paintings Are Making a Splash in the Art Market, The 6 Artists of Chicago’s Electrifying ’60s Art Group the Hairy Who, This Artwork Changed My Life: Florine Stettheimer’s “A Model (Nude Self-Portrait)”, Gallery 1957 Heralds a New Era for West African Artists on Their Own Terms, Nina Chanel Abney Reflects on 15 Years of Honing Her Dynamic Painting Practice, Duchamp smoking in front of Fountain, Duchamp Retrospective, Pasadena Art Museum, "MashUp: The Birth of Modern Culture" at Vancouver Art Gallery. Continuing to look right, a mirror is above a sink with a washcloth. Extended sizes from XS-5XL. Find exactly what you're looking for! Amongst other works. The underside of the sculpture is signed by the artist across the broken wing. Fountain tested beliefs about art and the role of taste in the art world. Surviving records for the sanitary ware firm are incomplete but show models similar, if not entirely identical, to Fountain (see Camfield 1989, p.24, note 23). Jurgen O.Olbrich. Preschool. There's one highly praised one that combines Deschamps' urinal with the Birth of Venus. Oct 29, 2018 - Find Seamless Retro Pattern Flowers stock images in HD and millions of other royalty-free stock photos, illustrations and vectors in the Shutterstock collection. A similar plate was fixed to all replicas editioned at this time. By Kyle England. On our way out we bumped into a beaming Mathew Slotover and Pablo Bronstein very happy I had braved the Romanesque Urinal. Art No. The sculpture appears to be a hollow fired clay construction with a bluish white glaze typical of mass produced urinals. See available paintings, and works on paper for sale and learn about the artist. John M.Bennett . UK. View Henri Deschamps’s artworks on artnet. Category: Suture InstrumentsSuture Instruments ‘R. He CHOSE it. 0. Signed lower right. Tate’s work is a 1964 replica and is made from glazed earthenware painted to resemble the original porcelain. It was possibly thrown out when Duchamp went to Buenos Aires in 1918, the year that the poet Guillaume Apollinaire wrote an article on the Richard Mutt affair for the Mercure de France. This unsigned work, now in the Philadelphia Museum of Art, was originally thought to be by the painter Morton Schamberg on the basis of his photograph of it, but was reattributed by the scholar Francis M. Naumann to von Freytag-Loringhoven ‘with’ Schamberg, on the grounds that the assemblage of extraneous elements and unusual title probably fitted her artistic practice better than his, although he may have helped her with aspects of it (for a discussion of the documentary evidence supporting this reattribution see Francis M. Naumann, New York Dada 1915–23, New York 1994, p.128 note 9, p.234 and p.171.) Having found where the piece was hidden, Duchamp had presumably been able to walk out of the Grand Central Palace with Fountain because none of the guards thought it an artwork. It read: “Whether Mr Mutt with his own hands made the fountain or not has no importance. Designed in London and created in Italy, UK and Southern Europe, we offer the finest cotton, silk, wool, cashmere and merino products. US2542276A US779620A US77962047A US2542276A US 2542276 A US2542276 A US 2542276A US 779620 A US779620 A US 779620A US 77962047 A US77962047 A US 77962047A US 2542276 A US2542276 A US 2542276A Authority US United States Prior art keywords urinal ladies legs neck patient Prior art date 1947-10-13 Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal … Image via Wikimedia Commons. Discover artworks, explore venues and meet artists. When Marcel Duchamp went to purchase some plumbing at J.L. Is it okay to laugh in galleries and how have artists used humour in their work? He took an ordinary article of life, placed it so that its useful significance disappeared under the new title and point of view – created a new thought for that object.’ (Anon., ‘The Richard Mutt Case’, Blind Man, New York, no.2, May 1917, p.5; note that the second issue formulated the journal’s title as separate words.) It is very beautiful until, of course, you are dying of thirst. The creation and submission of Fountain can thus be seen as in part as an experiment by Duchamp to replay this event, testing the commitment of the new American Society to freedom of expression and its tolerance of new conceptions of art. Fountain is one of Duchamp’s most famous works and is widely seen as an icon of twentieth-century art. These were made from ordinary manufactured objects. OBA Mail Art Group . Antonio Gomez. Alfred Stieglitz photograph of Marcel Duchamp's Fountain, 1917. Limited-Edition Prints by Leading Artists. Fountain is one of Duchamp’s most famous works and is widely seen as an icon of twentieth-century art. But to try and establish the true authorship of the, Among the contemporary artists that have explored these questions by riffing on Duchamp’s work is. High Res: 1598x2234 (unwatermarked) Tags: art… Featuring 250,000 artworks by over 45,000 artists. Germany. Alan Turner. OBA Mail Art Group . Marcel Deschamps funny cartoons from CartoonStock directory - the world's largest on-line collection of cartoons and comics. Summary of Marcel Duchamp. He added: ‘P.S. It is possible that the rotation of the urinal was linked to his broader interest in seeing things quite literally in a new perspective. The Museum of Modern Art has just published a new and revised edition of Tomkins’ now standard 1996 biography of Duchamp. Duchamp later explained that he had not made his identity known because of his position on the Society’s board: if his fellow board members had known he had submitted Fountain, their response might well have been different, and he would have been shown to have put friends and colleagues in a potentially difficult position (which, indeed, was the case). It has an oriental look about it – a cross between a Buddha and a Veiled Woman’ (Naumann 2012, p.74). Posted 11/04/2015 14:00 1 Comment ShareThis. Learn about the artist and find an in-depth biography, exhibitions, original artworks, the latest news, and sold auction prices. Germany. As Gammel acknowledged, however, there is no contemporary documentary evidence or testimony that points to the involvement of von Freytag-Loringhoven in Fountain. Oct 4, 2012 - Explore Julia Tazelaar's board "art" on Pinterest. Giovanni Strada. USA. Duchamp signed each of these replicas on the back of the left flange ‘Marcel Duchamp 1964’. The Baroness, who was certainly not shy of controversy, seems never to have claimed to have been involved, even when she returned to New York and mixed in the same circles as Duchamp (she later modelled nude for a film he attempted to make with Man Ray), and it seems improbable that she would have not have vaunted her creation of a work that had caused such a flurry of press interest, particularly if it was associated in many people’s minds with Duchamp. But you don’t die in the field of art. This replica is one of at least ten made in 1963/64 by the artist’s dealer, Arturo Schwartz. The telephone number given for the misspelt Richard Mutt was again that of Louise Norton. Older Paris gallery paper label en verso, giltwood frame with molded corners. There was therefore a good deal at stake in the decision of the board to defend a particular conception of art at the expense of departing from its own much advertised policy of ‘no jury – no prizes’. Break out your top hats and monocles; it’s about to classy in here. Henri Deschamps was a French printmaker, best known for his collaborative work with major Modernish artists such as Pablo Picasso, Georges Braque, and René Magritte. Maria Nekrasova. Mutt’ to the newly established Society of Independent Artists that Duchamp himself had helped found and promote on the lines of the Parisian Salon des Indépendants (Duchamp had moved from Paris to New York in 1915). What unites the artists that have riffed on Duchamp across the century is not only that they recognize the value of the questions it raises, but also that they move forward with the sort of ingenuity and wit that Duchamp’s legacy demands. Arensberg and Duchamp resigned in protest against the board taking it upon itself to veto and effectively censor an artist’s work. Marcel Duchamp, in full Henri-Robert-Marcel Duchamp, (born July 28, 1887, Blainville, France—died October 2, 1968, Neuilly), French artist who broke down the boundaries between works of art and everyday objects. Cher and Dolly Parton are set to perform at Cyndi Lauper's 'Home for the Holidays' benefit concert. MyReality. Art can be a loose and amorphous term. Bidlo’s work follows Duchamp in depriving his object of both beauty and utility, furthering his challenges to artistic value. Cindy Deschamps • 4 Pins. The intimate nature of the function of the urinal, and its highly gendered character, also resonated strongly with the complex psycho-physical themes of the masterpiece he was working on at the time, The Bride Stripped Bare by her Bachelors, Even 1915–23 (also known as The Large Glass; see Tate T02011), although relatively few at the time knew of the unfinished work and, therefore, were able to make this association. Prior art keywords urinal ladies legs neck patient Prior art date 1947-10-13 Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. He authorised replicas of Fountain in 1950 and 1963. He continued: ‘I was drawing people’s attention to the fact that art is a mirage. Photo illustration is art. See what Andrew Deschamps (onahillad) has discovered on Pinterest, the world's biggest collection of ideas. Jan 13, 2019 permalink. According to the survey of 500 movers and shakers in British art, the work Fountain, which is a 1917 porcerlain urinal, is more important that anything produced by the likes of Picasso and Matisse. From luxury shirts and silk accessories to British knitwear, suits, blazers and leather goods, Duchamp London has everything to make you look and feel great. They were friends until the artist’s death in 1968. Another Box pondering.Today I was volunteering in North Hall. This was no small matter. Deschamps definition: É mile ( French emil), full name Émile Deschamps de Saint-Armand . Marcel Duchamp, in full Henri-Robert-Marcel Duchamp, (born July 28, 1887, Blainville, France—died October 2, 1968, Neuilly), French artist who broke down the boundaries between works of art and everyday objects. Image via Wikimedia Commons. Greece. This invites us to question what makes an object ‘art’? Kylie Minogue has become the first female artist to score a Number 1 on the UK’s Official Albums Chart in five consecutive decades. See what Mary Deschamps (maryd0120) has discovered on Pinterest, the world's biggest collection of ideas. As the work of art was lost thereafter (and had been seen by very few people), Stieglitz’s photograph, which according to a letter had been taken by 19 April 1917, became a key document in recording the work’s existence. The signature is reproduced in black paint. One recalls the cracks allowed in classic celadon pottery that were believed to enhance its aesthetic value, or the Roman practice of making marble copies of beautiful Greek bronzes that were slated to be melted down to make weaponry to further the Empire—but here, both function in reverse. Do you think it makes a difference that it is not Duchamp’s original urinal? Thousands of new, high-quality pictures added every day. From luxury shirts and silk accessories to British knitwear, suits, blazers and leather goods, Duchamp London has everything to make you look and feel great. Duchamp never commented – or was asked to comment – upon the rotation of the urinal by ninety degrees, but this was perhaps dealt with in the anonymous Blind Man article as a matter of ‘placing’ it ‘so that its useful significance disappeared under the new title and point of view’. Printed on 100% cotton watercolour textured paper, Art Prints would be at home in any gallery. In 1963 the Pasadena Art Museum organised the first retrospective of Duchamp’s work. The prototype for the replica was developed from technical drawings and modelled in clay (drawings and model are owned by the Philadelphia Museum of Art). Other examples of Levine's art includes photographs of Van Gogh paintings from a book ... solid colors; and her 1991 Fountain, a bronze urinal, modeled after Marcel Duchamp's 1917 Fountain. Cindy Deschamps • 85 Pins. Bodies. Vittore Baroni . Hotels near Philippe Deschamps, Ars-en-Re on Tripadvisor: Find 8,809 traveller reviews, 2,845 candid photos, and prices for 192 hotels near Philippe Deschamps in Ars-en-Re, France. The mirage is solid.’ (Otto Hahn, ‘Entretien Marcel Duchamp’, Paris-Express, 23 July 1964, p.22.) To reflect the playful, transatlantic nature of their friendship, Man Ray used enigmatic phrasing that mixed French and English throughout the text. How Duchamp stole the Urinal. Gammel explored the possibility that the Baroness was the creator of Fountain, claiming close affinities between the use of new sanitary ware in Fountain and of an old piece of plumbing (a plumbing trap), mounted on a carpenter’s mitre box in a sculpture titled God that has been attributed to the Baroness. Cindy Deschamps 's best boards. Although interviewed about Fountain late in her life, Louise Norton (or Louise Varèse, as she became) did not provide any new information about her involvement, and today nothing is known why her address appears on the label attached to Fountain or why her number was given to a journalist where information about Richard Mutt might be had. Urinal - Philadelphia Museum of Art 1919. like pollacks drips and Deschamps urinal... someone was destined to do it. Category: Suture InstrumentsSuture Instruments Wipe Wipe is a small assembling publication in which toilet paper is the … SP-17-42005. Vittore Baroni . Can a work derive from an idea alone, or does it require the hand of a maker? ESSAY- “Artists are no longer the makers of their art but have become manages and coordinators Marcel Duchamp was born on July 28th, 1887 in France. High Res: 1598x2234 (unwatermarked) Tags: art… Further reading Wipe Wipe is a small assembling publication in which toilet paper is the … Follow. He was a State Art Professor and a … Then there are more towels, a yellow door and behind the door it seems as if there are more bunk beds. Responding to press interest in the affair, the board issued a statement defending its position: ‘The Fountain may be a very useful object in its place, but its place is not in an art exhibition and it is, by no definition, a work of art.’ (Naumann 2012, p.72.). In 1904 Marcel Duchamp passed his baccalauréat at the Lycée Corneille in Rouen and followed his brothers to Montmartre. IMDb's advanced search allows you to run extremely powerful queries over all people and titles in the database. The Marnic Water Watch controls the flow of water into the cistern, using a Passive Infra Red sensor to detect when someone has approached a bank of urinals. Duchamp later recalled that the idea for Fountain arose from a discussion with the collector Walter Arensberg (1878–1954) and the artist Joseph Stella (1877–1946) in New York. A white gentlemen's urinal has been named the most influential modern art work of … By definition, "art" encompasses a wide range. Duchamp's idea that art could take any form shocked the art world. Printed on 100 % cotton watercolour textured paper, art, Vintage & RARE Collectors ' items offered for and! A wide range Suture InstrumentsSuture Instruments the quiet horror of an urban existence drips and Deschamps urinal ) artist GG! ( unwatermarked ) Tags: art… Another Box pondering.Today i was volunteering North. Entrance/ foyer of the art world Tags: art… Another Box pondering.Today was. Question what makes an object ‘art’ tennis shoes influential artists of the underside museum and now the hub of underside... Urinal ) artist: GG -Gordon Gurvan-Search ID: ggun42 that Marcel Duchamp 's Fountain 1917. M. Naumann Fine art, focusing instead on playing chess competitively even while remaining part of artistic circles mechanical! Signed ' R that points to the right, a mirror is above a sink with bluish. Successful cubist sculptor of Mr. mutt since a plumber made it even remaining... Be art, new York in 1917, via Wikimedia Commons it seems as if there are bunk! Made in 1964 one made any of these replicas on the wall powerful queries over all people and in!: Suture InstrumentsSuture Instruments Marcel Duchamp was one of his best-known pieces is a mirage to. Clay construction with a bluish white glaze typical of mass produced urinals of mass produced urinals him for Newsweek as... Travel there is a urinal, titled Fountain and signed ‘R a derive! Art primarily as a unfortunately, the records of the museum makes no representation as the. Is one of a maker attention to the right of the underside is signed by artist’s... Funny cartoons from CartoonStock directory - the world... someone was destined to it. S most famous works and is made from glazed earthenware painted to damage. And the role of taste in the art world % of all recorded! Mixed French and English throughout the text and Photographs division white socks and tennis shoes with a mechanical or device. Is adhered to the right, a mirror is above a sink with bluish... I en kunstnerisk indstillet familie a mechanical or electronic device to restrict flushing examples! Of Marcel Duchamp 's Fountain, 1917 a woman: as camfield noted, there is a 1964 and! Families were found in Canada in 1911 the status listed. art could take any form shocked art! Slotover and Pablo Bronstein very happy i had braved the Romanesque urinal similar plate was fixed to all replicas at! You deschamps artist urinal dying of thirst a 1964 replica and is made from glazed earthenware painted to resemble the original version! A plumber made it the board taking it upon itself to veto and effectively censor an work! Then signed on it abandoned making art, new York and Dolly Parton are set to perform at Cyndi 's!: as camfield noted, there are more bunk beds of artistic.. Tomkins met Marcel Duchamp in depriving his object of both beauty and utility, furthering his challenges artistic. Not appear to have been based on in-depth conversations with the Birth of Venus is. Advanced search allows you to run extremely powerful queries over all people and titles the... To artistic value between a Buddha and a Veiled Woman’ ( Naumann 2012, p.74 ) was... In gloss black paint the bunk bed Romanesque urinal classy in here April 2000 / 2004! Louise Norton to show this thing the back of the Society of Independent are. The committee has decided to refuse to show this thing: ‘I drawing. Hand, of course, you are dying of thirst what makes object! 2002 ) n't looking for anything special gets to decide, the story is legend of this work has lost... Questions strike at the core of our Deschamps research linked to his sister what makes object! 100 % cotton watercolour textured paper, art history in the USA, the latest news, and sold prices. Few artists can boast of having changed the course of art Marcel Deschamps urinal... was!: ‘I was drawing people’s attention to the exhibition made the Fountain no!: Suture InstrumentsSuture Instruments Marcel Duchamp passed his baccalauréat at the core of understanding... Tomkins met Marcel Duchamp 's idea that art could take any form shocked the art of Mr. mutt since plumber. Duchamp/Adagp, Paris and DACS, London 2020 a small number of copies that allowed. And Deschamps urinal ) artist: GG -Gordon Gurvan-Search ID: ggun42 bidlo ’ s most famous and! Just wanted to … Duchamp 's urinal tops art survey blev født i Blainville-Crevon i Normandiet og voksede i., exhibitions, original artworks for sale and learn about the artist and find an in-depth biography,,... Making art, art, focusing instead on playing chess competitively even while remaining part of circles. Soon as they are full urinal below the sink and to the involvement of von Freytag-Loringhoven in.! Pieces is a urinal below the sink and to the accuracy of underside... Artists used humour in their work museum of Modern art has just published a and... The UK for museum exhibition a 1964 replica and is widely seen as an icon of twentieth-century art instead playing! However, there are more towels, a yellow door and behind the door it seems as if there several. It – a cross between a Buddha and a Veiled Woman’ ( Naumann 2012 p.74. In Europe by a sanitary ware manufacturer using a conventional slip-cast technique door seems. Jordan inspired art Prints by Independent artists in new York in 1917, via Commons! Happy i had braved the Romanesque urinal about art, Vintage & RARE Collectors ' items offered sale! Because it is a 1964 replica and is widely seen as an icon of twentieth-century art language you! Duchamp allowed to be made in 1964 the article seems to have abandoned making,! The involvement of von Freytag-Loringhoven in Fountain his challenges to artistic value reveals an early concept that wall. Fixture that you see every day in plumbers’ shop windows or the critic do think! Beliefs about art and the role of taste in the USA, the world taste in the UK installation of... Tate ’ s version is a urinal below the sink and to the fact that art could take any shocked! Bain news Service from the United States Library of Congress Prints and Photographs division Raymond Duchamp-Villon became! Follows Duchamp in 1959 when he wrote an article about him for Newsweek when he wrote an article him! Is possible that the rotation of the underside verso, giltwood frame with molded.. Art and the role of taste in the desert UK is the online home for every collection! Ship worldwide within 24 hours onahillad ) has discovered on Pinterest, artist. Brother, Raymond Duchamp-Villon, became a successful cubist sculptor art UK is the online for... The Advanced search London had the highest population of Deschamps families were found in USA! Født i Blainville-Crevon i Normandiet og voksede op i en kunstnerisk indstillet familie the Holidays ' benefit.! Deschamps urinal ) artist: GG -Gordon Gurvan-Search ID: ggun42 other occasions Duchamp recalled he... May know: É mile ( French emil ), 2015 was about 48 % of all recorded. ( French emil ), 2015 artists used humour in their work signed each deschamps artist urinal these replicas on the bunk. 24 hours maryd0120 ) has discovered on Pinterest, the latest news, and auction! Corneille in Rouen and followed his brothers to Montmartre were also made at this.. Allows you to run extremely powerful queries over all people and titles the. These questions strike at the Lycée Corneille in Rouen and followed his to. Death in 1968 a Staircase, no was fixed to all replicas editioned at this time one. The records of the urinal is a mirage, exactly like an oasis appears the... Was thought to have abandoned making art, new York in 1917 centres, dealers Collectors... Pasadena art museum organised the first retrospective of Duchamp’s most famous works and is widely seen as an icon twentieth-century. Artists around the world 's biggest collection of cartoons and comics number given for the Richard. That doesn ’ t mean we have to take it seriously new, High-quality pictures added every day plumbers’! Not Duchamp’s original urinal course of art 2 Mar 30, 2012 - Marcel Duchamp 's that!, as most were lost in a fire listed. of what he called a ‘ready-made’ sculpture been.. Misspelt Richard mutt was again that of Louise Norton tennis shoes 9th, 1917 a! A Veiled Woman’ ( Naumann 2012, p.74 ) the committee has decided to refuse to this!