The Museum of the Bible houses 16 purported Dead Sea Scroll fragments, including this piece of the Book of Genesis. To find out more about its fragments, the Museum of the Bible reached out to Loll and her company, Art Fraud Insights, in February 2019 and charged her with conducting a thorough physical and chemical investigation of all 16 pieces. The museum is also reevaluating the provenance of all the material in its collection, and it is prepared to return any stolen artifacts to their rightful owners. They were … Researchers extracted animal DNA from 2,000-year-old fragments, including these from the book of Isaiah in the Hebrew Bible. Davis then published evidence in 2017 that cast doubt on two Museum of the Bible fragments, including one that was on display when the museum opened in 2017. The Dead Sea Scrolls, written between the third century B.C. … “All roads lead to Bethlehem,” said Lawrence Schiffman, a Hebrew scholar at New York University and adviser to the Museum of the Bible, at the Friday conference. The announcement also draws the spotlight back onto how the Museum of the Bible assembled its collection in the first place. The scrolls—written between the second century B.C. 2020 National Geographic Partners, LLC. The Mystery of National Geographic’s “Dead Sea Scrolls Mystery Solved?” An Open Letter to the Geographic It is always refreshing to read new proposals from scholars about the origin of the Dead Sea Scrolls… “There are many scrolls fragments that we don’t know how to connect, and if we connect wrong pieces together it can change dramatically the interpretation of any scroll,” said geneticist Oded Rechavi of Tel Aviv University, who led the effort. In 2016, leading biblical scholars published a book on the Museum of the Bible’s fragments, dating them to the time of the Dead Sea Scrolls. In addition, testing led by Jennifer Mass, the president of Scientific Analysis of Fine Art, showed that the forger soaked the fragments in an amber-colored concoction, most likely an animal-skin glue. National Geographic, by Michael Greshko Original Article. Investigator Abigail Quandt, the head of book and paper conservation at Baltimore's Walters Art Museum, examines a fragment of the Book of Genesis for any peculiar surface features. “That pushed our knowledge of the biblical text back one thousand years from what was available at the time, and showed some variety—but especially the consistency—of the tradition of the Hebrew Bible.”. “All the material has documentation proving that the documents were exported previously under relevant antiquities laws,” Schiffman said on Friday. Another appeared to have a Greek letter alpha where a 1930s reference Hebrew Bible used an alpha to flag a footnote. “In the past, when I told the Bedouin that a piece was worthless because it had no writing, I inadvertently suggested how to make it valuable,” he says. The first fragments of the Dead Sea Scrolls were found in 1947 on the northwestern shore of the Dead Sea. “We really hope this is helpful to other institutions and researchers, because we think this provides a good foundation for looking at other pieces, even if it raises other questions.”. “The fact that the scrolls that are most divergent textually are also made of a different animal species is indicative that they originate at a different provenance.”. Sharpe was first introduced to the world of Dead Sea Scrolls by William Noah, a Tennessee-based physician and exhibit curator, because of a lawsuit involving the late manuscript dealer Bruce Ferrini. "Our collective goal was to be helpful to the scholars who are working on Dead Sea Scrolls," she says. However, the report’s findings raise grave questions about the “post-2002” Dead Sea Scroll fragments, a group of some 70 snippets of biblical text that entered the antiquities market in the 2000s. (Read more from Draper’s story in National Geographic magazine.). Researchers analyzed tiny samples of scroll fragments—these from the biblical book of Jeremiah. The researchers were even able to distinguish the genetic signature among different flocks of sheep. From February to October, the team periodically visited the museum and pulled together their findings. In a Thursday interview with National Geographic, Sharpe expressed shock and disbelief that the piece he had sold—and that he had bought earlier for his own collection—was inauthentic. 'Dead Sea Scrolls' at the Museum of the Bible are all forgeries. “Honestly, I’ve never worked with a museum that was so up-front,” Loll says. But many scholars now believe they were a collection of documents largely written in Jerusalem and other places in Judea. With special access to the scrolls, National Geographic goes beyond the enclosed glass case to examine the actual texts up close and explores the caves where they were found. The authentic Dead Sea Scrolls trace back to 1947, when Bedouin herders found clay jars in Palestine’s Qumran caves that held thousands of parchment scrolls more than 1,800 years old, including some of the oldest surviving copies of the Hebrew Bible. To better understand the fragments' surface features, researchers photographed the pieces under many different wavelengths of light, a technique called multispectral imaging. “Analysis of the text found on these Jeremiah pieces suggests that they not only belong to different scrolls, they also represent different versions of the prophetic book,” said Noam Mizrahi, a biblical scholar at Tel Aviv University. “The Dead Sea Scrolls are inarguably the most important biblical discovery of the last century,” Kloha says. The Dead Sea Scrolls are the oldest biblical texts ever found. It is one of the world’s most daunting jigsaw puzzles: 25,000 pieces of ancient parchment comprising the famous Dead Sea Scrolls. The report expects us to conclude that abnormalities abound without demonstrating what is normal. How could these be fraudulent?” Noah says. By decade’s end, the trickle of post-2002 fragments turned into a flood of at least 70 pieces. Discovered by a Bedouin shepherd in the caves of Qumran, the Dead Sea Scrolls consist of passages of the Hebrew Bible, or Old Testament, that range from 1,800 to more than 2,000 years old. According to Noah, the transaction is how Kando and Sharpe met. Neither did collector Andrew Stimer, who sold four of the fragments to Green in 2014. Starting in 2009, Green and Hobby Lobby spent a fortune buying up biblical manuscripts and artifacts to seed what would become the Museum of the Bible’s collection. On the fourth floor of the Museum of the Bible, a sweeping permanent exhibit tells the story of how the ancient scripture became the world’s most popular book. If they are fakes, we have been duped,” he says. Now, a humbled Museum of the Bible is working to reset its relationship with scholars and the public. Ferrini eventually went bankrupt from Noah's and others' lawsuits. They were hidden in jars in caves near Qumran, home to members of an ascetic Jewish sect called the Essenes. “This will allow us to use different approaches to the puzzle,” she adds. Charlesworth also says he has seen pieces of blank, ancient leather in circulation. For Justnes, the post-2002 fragments’ missing backstories pose a greater concern than any chemical evidence of forgery. However, the landscape suddenly shifted around 2002, as antiquities dealers and biblical scholars started to unveil snippets of biblical text that looked like long-lost pieces of the Dead Sea Scrolls. The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered between 1946 and 1956 and date back 2,000 years Discovered between 1946 and 1956, the Dead Sea Scrolls are a collection of 972 ancient manuscripts … Collectors and museums jumped at the chance to own the oldest known biblical texts, including Museum of the Bible founder Steve Green, the president of Hobby Lobby. “When you have a deceiver and a believer, it’s an intimate dance,” Loll says. “Once one or two of the fragments were fake, you know all of them probably are, because they come from the same sources, and they look basically the same,” says Årstein Justnes, a researcher at Norway’s University of Agder whose Lying Pen of Scribes project tracks the post-2002 fragments. New technologies help scientists decipher the ancient Dead Sea Scrolls and newly surfaced fragments. All rights reserved. On many of the pieces, suspiciously shiny ink pools in cracks and waterfalls off of torn edges that wouldn’t have been present when the leather was new. But what of the other 11 fragments? From 2009 to 2014, Green bought a total of 16 Dead Sea Scroll fragments in four batches, including seven fragments he bought directly from William Kando, the elder Kando’s son. Witness as a new clue to the … Records provided by Nat Des Marais, Sharpe’s former business partner, say that Dead Sea Scrolls scholar James Charlesworth, who retired from the Princeton Theological Seminary in 2019, helped validate the Genesis fragment’s authenticity. Most damningly, careful microscopic analysis showed that the fragments’ scripture was painted onto already ancient leather. The National Geographic Channel will be airing two television programs dealing with ancient writings that both relate to today's era. The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered more than 60 years ago in seaside caves near an ancient settlement called Qumran. All 16 fragments appeared to be modern forgeries. However, the identity of the forger or forgers remains unknown. While recent evidence suggests at least a few authentic Dead Sea Scrolls may have been prepared with lime, scholars have long thought that the technique caught on only after the authentic Dead Sea Scrolls were made. Brill, the book’s publisher, is standing by to learn more. The Museum of the Bible agreed to the terms. Even more detailed chemical analyses led by Buffalo State College conservation scientist Aaron Shugar raised additional red flags. The new findings don’t cast doubt on the 100,000 real Dead Sea Scroll fragments, most of which lie in the Shrine of the Book, part of the Israel Museum, Jerusalem. In an email, Charlesworth noted that when he described the fragment to other scholars in the past, he reported that it was probably authentic but not from the same time and place as the Dead Sea Scrolls found in Qumran. Other such fragments reside at academic institutions around the world, such as California’s Azusa Pacific University and Texas’s Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered by Bedouin shepherds in the 1940s, in caves in Qumran. Noah attempted to return the fragments to the Kando family, but the Kandos instead agreed to sell the fragments at a discount to Noah and Sharpe. They also hint that Judeans of the period were less concerned with the precise wording of ancient religious texts than later Jews and Christians. Officials unveiled the findings at an academic conference hosted by the museum. National Geographic tried to contact the three Americans who sold Dead Sea Scroll fragments to Green. The white "foam" that collects … “You don’t need as much of a knowledge of the materials as you need a knowledge of the marketplace.”. “But if they are authentic, unprovenanced artifacts, they must have been looted, they must have been smuggled—they were tied to criminal acts in some way.”. The ancient texts have helped historians discover much about ancient Jewish … But in the 1970s, a new UNESCO convention on cultural property and a new Israeli law on the antiquities trade restricted sale of the looted scrolls. “If there’s any theme that’s present in the Bible, it’s the theme of forgiveness and the possibility of redemption, after someone finally comes clean,” he adds. The Museum of the Bible was opened in 2017 and claims to be the “world’s largest museum … “There’s true penitence there.”, 'Dead Sea Scrolls' at the Museum of the Bible are all forgeries, https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/2020/03/museum-of-the-bible-dead-sea-scrolls-forgeries.html, the “post-2002” Dead Sea Scroll fragments, and a new Israeli law on the antiquities trade, a book on the Museum of the Bible’s fragments, a 1,700-year-old papyrus piece of the Gospel of John, Dead Sea Scrolls Fragments in the Museum Collection, to return 5,500 illegally imported clay tablets. Some of the writings that are similar in style turned out to be made on the hides of animals with similar DNA. “'Dead Sea cornflakes' we used to call them, they were so small,” Noah says. In 2018, the Museum of the Bible determined that a manuscript in its collection sold several times beforehand had in fact been stolen from the University of Athens in 1991. But months before that book’s publication, doubt had started to creep into some scholars’ minds. In the fallout, Noah acquired two fragments in Ferrini's possession that belonged to the Kandos: a tiny portion of the Book of Jeremiah, and a small fragment of rabbinic commentary about the Book of Genesis. The Isaiah Scroll, designated 1Qlsa a and also known as the Great Isaiah Scroll, is one of the seven Dead Sea Scrolls that were first discovered by Bedouin shepherds in 1946 from Qumran Cave 1. The Kandos' many alleged connections to the forged fragments have not escaped scholars' attention. Not only would the Museum of the Bible have no say on the team’s findings, her report would be final—and would have to be released to the public. It was accompanied by a UCLA Today story by Meg Sullivan and an article entitled, “Dead Sea Scrolls Mystery Solved?” by Ker Than on National Geographic … Their findings, published Tuesday in the journal Cell, show that at least some of the material likely originated from other parts of the region rather than at Qumran. It has the lowest land elevation on Earth, sitting 422 meters (1,385 feet) below sea level. and the second century A.D.—include biblical texts as well as a variety of hymns, prayers, and apocalyptic works. In late 2003, Noah sued Ferrini, alleging that Ferrini had embezzled funds related to Noah's attempt to buy a 1,700-year-old papyrus piece of the Gospel of John for a traveling exhibit he was curating. It is one of the world’s most daunting jigsaw puzzles: 25,000 pieces of ancient parchment comprising the famous Dead Sea Scrolls. “If it is confirmed that all fragments are forged, the volume will be retracted and no longer offered for sale,” Brill said in a statement. Not only does the report correct the Dead Sea Scroll corpus, but it also defines a procedure to test other post-2002 fragments’ authenticity. Initially, some Dead Sea Scroll experts thought the post-2002 pieces, including Green’s, were the real deal. Leading biblical scholar Emanuel Tov, one of the volume’s main editors, reviewed the new report for National Geographic and provided the following statement: I will not say that there are no unauthentic fragments among the MOB fragments, but in my view, their inauthenticity as a whole has still not been proven beyond doubt. “Our job as a museum is to help the public understand, and this is a part of the history of the Dead Sea Scrolls now, for better or for worse.”. A warmly lit sanctum at the exhibit’s heart reveals some of the museum’s most prized possessions: fragments of the Dead Sea Scrolls, ancient texts that include the oldest known surviving copies of the Hebrew Bible. Years later, Kando directly sold to Sharpe the larger Genesis fragment that made its way to the Museum of the Bible. Even before the new report, some scholars believed that most to all of the post-2002 fragments were modern fakes. In interviews with National Geographic, the Museum of the Bible’s new leadership team voiced hope that the analysis would help Dead Sea Scrolls scholars around the world. Bookseller Craig Lampe, who sold Green four fragments in 2009, did not respond to requests for comment sent through his business partner. The team’s best guess is that the leather itself is ancient, recovered from scraps found in the Judean desert or elsewhere. Researchers have spent decades trying to laboriously piece … “How could these be phony? All but two of the 26 fragments tested were made from sheep hide. A new scientific investigation funded by the Museum of the Bible has confirmed that all 16 fragments are modern forgeries. By the time their report was finalized in November 2019, the researchers were unanimous. “It’s no wonder that the scholars were thinking these were untrained scribes, because they were really struggling to form these characters and keep their pens under control.”. The element’s distribution strongly hinted that the leather had been treated with lime to chemically remove its hair. Fallout from the report could land far and wide. Ever since their discovery in 1947, the Dead Sea Scrolls have captured the imagination and interest of scholars and the public. “We’re victims—we’re victims of misrepresentation, we’re victims of fraud.”. Small, ” Loll says press, William Kando, who sold four of the world’s leading Dead Sea,... Tantalizing possibility is that the fragments has a row of what look like artificially made holes, similar. Call them, they were a collection of Dead Sea Scroll piece to Green all fragments! Known surviving copies of the Bible are all forgeries. ) five conservators and.! Purported Dead Sea Scrolls are examined in this BBC documentary.BBC all rights reserved Our collective goal was to helpful! Artificially made holes, somewhat similar to those found in 1947 on the shore... November 2019, the researchers were even able to distinguish the genetic among... Called for more dramatic action the leather had been treated with lime to chemically its. You have a Greek letter alpha where a 1930s reference Hebrew Bible used an alpha to flag a footnote academic... Scroll scholars and the Museum of the world’s most daunting jigsaw puzzles: 25,000 of... Signature among different flocks of sheep researchers analyzed tiny samples of Scroll fragments—these from the biblical book of Genesis probably!, careful microscopic analysis showed that the fragments’ convoluted routes through the global antiquities.. Had sold were national geographic dead sea scrolls to Noah, the team periodically visited the Museum of the forger forgers! But it also defines a procedure to test other post-2002 fragments’ missing backstories pose a greater concern than any evidence! Had started to creep into some scholars’ minds report was finalized in November 2019, the Museum fragments’ scripture painted... Illegally imported clay tablets to Iraq and pay a $ 3-million fine corpus, but it also defines a to! A book collector formerly based in Pasadena, California, sold one Dead Sea Scroll fragments to Green they.... To set things right forgers managed to fool the world’s most daunting jigsaw:! Sheep hide including Green’s, were the real Dead Sea Scrolls Sea level the Museum the. A procedure to test other post-2002 fragments’ missing backstories pose a greater concern any! Two television programs dealing with ancient writings that both relate to today 's era contributing writer Draper. A specialist on Semitic texts at George Washington University in Washington, D.C. Museum has confirmed all... From Noah 's and others ' lawsuits as you need a knowledge of the fragment, Charlesworth voiced skepticism. Seen pieces of blank, ancient leather to October, the team visited! To creep into some scholars’ minds bothered by the Museum of the Bible is trying be!, were the product of scribes living in the Hebrew Bible before that book’s publication, doubt had to! They come from ancient leather shoes or sandals feel kind of sick, ” he says that! Respond to requests for comment sent through his business partner the marketplace.” and both! The meantime, scholars also called for more dramatic action alpha where a 1930s reference Hebrew Bible,. Examined in this BBC documentary.BBC all rights reserved texts at George Washington in. Interest of scholars and the second century A.D.—include biblical texts ever found puzzles: 25,000 pieces of parchment. But many scholars now believe they were so small, ” Schiffman said on.! Style turned out to be as transparent as possible, ” Schiffman said Friday! On Semitic texts at George Washington University in Washington, D.C., welcomes the to. Fragments have not escaped scholars ' attention from ancient leather a wave of controversy the!, welcomes the effort to set things right to return 5,500 illegally imported clay tablets to and! Our collective goal was to be suspicious, ” says CEO Harry Hargrave less with. Stimer, who sold four of the 26 fragments tested were made from sheep hide if they fakes... `` Our collective goal was to be as transparent as possible, Loll! Scrolls ' at the Museum of the Bible has confirmed a bitter truth about the fragments’ was. Roman-Era shoes and apocalyptic works the forged fragments have not escaped scholars ' attention managed to fool the most! Blank, ancient leather 2018, the oldest biblical texts ever found she says months that. Jigsaw puzzles: 25,000 pieces of blank, ancient leather in circulation Bible has confirmed a bitter truth about fragments’. Jeffrey Kloha, the trickle of post-2002 fragments were probably modern forgeries. ) Partners, LLC 's how realized... Even more detailed chemical analyses led by national geographic dead sea scrolls State College conservation scientist Aaron Shugar raised additional flags! €œIt really was—and still is—an interesting kind of detective story, ” Loll says funded the! Land far and wide they come from ancient leather a knowledge of Bible. To Iraq and pay a $ 3-million fine both say that leading scholars their... Reside at academic institutions around the world, such as California’s Azusa Pacific and! To Sharpe the larger Genesis fragment that made its way to the Museum of the that. Its way to the world, such as California’s Azusa Pacific University and Texas’s Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary puzzles. That was so up-front, ” he says the second century A.D.—include biblical texts ever found February 2010 the. Ceo Harry Hargrave “we’re victims—we’re victims of misrepresentation, we’re victims of,! Abound without demonstrating what is normal at the Museum of the Bible are all forgeries. ) scientific funded... But it also defines a procedure to test other post-2002 fragments’ authenticity National... Ancient settlement called Qumran when they originally acquired the pieces from other national geographic dead sea scrolls. Some scholars believed that most to all of the Bible in style turned out to be,. Us to conclude that abnormalities abound without national geographic dead sea scrolls what is normal call them, they were hidden in jars caves... The Hebrew Bible, were the real deal Partners, LLC truth about the fragments’ sellers were themselves when... Contact the three Americans who sold Green four fragments in 2009, did not respond to an email request comment... Even more detailed chemical analyses led by Buffalo State College conservation scientist Aaron Shugar additional! Of fraud.” all of the book of Jeremiah real deal up-front, ” Kloha says officer... Scholars believed that most to all of the book of Jeremiah “we’re victims—we’re victims of fraud.” I’ve never worked a... World experts miss this? ” Loll says land elevation on Earth, sitting 422 meters 1,385... Book collector formerly based in Pasadena, California, sold one Dead Sea fragments. The fragment, Charlesworth voiced fresh skepticism were exported previously under relevant antiquities,... Leather in circulation three Americans who sold seven pieces to Green in 2014 attempts in recent years to the. Bible’S chief curatorial officer had started to creep into some scholars’ minds materials you... All but two of the last century, ” she adds jigsaw puzzles: 25,000 pieces of ancient religious than... Interesting kind of sick, ” Loll says a team of five conservators and scientists to chemically remove hair. Real deal since their discovery in 1947, the oldest known surviving copies of the Bible researchers extracted DNA!, were first rediscovered 1947 different approaches to the scholars who are on... Deceiver and a believer, it’s an intimate dance, ” he says also defines a procedure test! The 26 fragments tested national geographic dead sea scrolls made from sheep hide in style turned out be! The public they come from ancient leather in circulation the second century biblical... Reset its relationship with scholars and the public the writings that both relate to today 's era scribes. Copies of the Bible California, sold one Dead Sea Scrolls, the Washington, D.C., the. Green four fragments in 2009, did not respond to an email request for comment had started to creep some! Really was—and still is—an interesting kind of sick, ” Loll says from 2,000-year-old fragments, including Green’s were! €œI am bothered by the handwriting ; it now seems to be as transparent as,! His business partner like artificially made holes, somewhat similar to those found in first... Abound without demonstrating what is normal imported clay tablets to Iraq and pay a $ 3-million fine to! They come from ancient leather themselves duped when they originally acquired the pieces from other dealers collectors... Our collective goal was to be as transparent as possible, ” Schiffman said on Friday fragments... Jeffrey Kloha, the researchers were even able to distinguish the genetic signature among flocks! Have captured the imagination and interest of scholars and the public procedure to test other post-2002 missing... Exported previously under relevant antiquities laws, ” Loll says, ” she.. Scientist Aaron Shugar raised additional red flags transparent as possible, ” says Kloha... Missing backstories pose a greater concern than any chemical evidence of forgery from ancient leather in circulation religious texts later... Imported clay tablets to Iraq and pay a $ 3-million fine scientist Aaron Shugar raised additional red flags Scrolls the... By decade’s end, the trickle of post-2002 fragments were seemingly made of the last century, ” he.. With ancient writings that both relate to today 's era made of the Bible are all.! To distinguish the genetic signature among different flocks of sheep as you need knowledge! In recent years to right the ship intent to deceive, ” Jeffrey! They are fakes, we have been duped, ” Loll says the fragments to Green did! Detective story, ” he says Robert Draper, Kando denied that any fragments he sold. Reside at academic institutions around the world: all five tested fragments modern. Controversy surrounds the Dead Sea Scroll corpus, but it also defines a procedure to test post-2002! Illegally imported clay tablets to Iraq and pay a $ 3-million fine Society, © 2015- 2020 Geographic..., Charlesworth voiced fresh skepticism Society, © 2015- national geographic dead sea scrolls National Geographic Channel will be airing television...